Please read my disclosure policy. 5. For my mother’s peasant bread recipe, these are the proportions: You can use any amount of starter you have on hand — just adapt the recipe accordingly. In this video I'll show you a quick hack to know when bulk fermentation of your sourdough is complete. I am a huge proponent of purchasing a starter, which is guaranteed to be vigorous nearly from the get go. It is my present thought that if we shorten the BF, we will be able to handle the dough during the pre-shape and shape with much less damage to the aveoli. Preheat oven safe pot with a sheet pan placed over top or vice versa: a sheet pan with a pot inverted over top. If you are not measuring your flour, salt, water, and sourdough starter with a digital scale, that is the first change you need to make. Another option: place your Dutch oven on a broiling pan. Ensuring the right temperature is especially important during the bulk fermentation (the first rise). I can’t encourage you enough to invest in one of the two pots mentioned above. The more sourdough I bake, the more I find it beneficial to stop the bulk fermentation when the dough has increased by roughly 50% in volume. The first rise takes place after we mix the ingredients. I love adding cornmeal, both for flavor and texture, into my bread doughs: A common question I get is: What do you do with all of the discard? Buy spring water. A few thoughts. People love incorporating rye and whole wheat flours into their breads mostly for health reasons but also for flavor. If you live in a humid environment, your dough may look soupier. Thank you for your input! Thank you again, I really appreciate your time :). A sharp blade helps. So, unless you’re worried about amassing too much starter, you don’t need to discard before the second feeding. Just so you know, however, there is no right way to do it, but the idea behind discarding a lot of your starter before feeding it (especially if it’s been stashed in the fridge or even left at room temperature for a long period without a feeding) is to remove a lot of acid — sometimes this is called the “acid load”. Then proceed with the recipe through the shaping step. Always measure by weight, and take notes. Using too much whole wheat flour, rye flour, or freshly milled flour. I'm including a photo of my first batch of bread since the same thing happened with this one. Here are two easy sourdough boule recipes to test out this schedule: Good oven spring is based on a number of factors. in the early part of the bulk fermentation after you’ve done at least one set of stretches and folds. The bulk fermentation is the dough’s first rise: it’s the time period that begins when the dough is mixed and ends when it is shaped. First Proof. That said, this is true up to a point: if you make a loaf with 400-500 g flour and use 200 g sourdough starter, it is going to taste sour due to the high percentage of sourdough starter in the mix, which will lend a lot of sour flavor. Please, teach me your ways. What is your opinion on this? If the autolyse, or rest, is more than 30 minutes, the yeast is added later so that it doesn’t start to ferment before mixing.” The Bread Bible, by Rose Levy Beranbaum, pg 55 Yeast does most of its work during this time, consuming sugars to produce carbon dioxide gas bubbles, which inflates gluten structure. When you set out to make a loaf of sourdough bread, you first need to make sure your starter is ready — it has to be strong enough to transform a mass of dough into a lofty boule. 1. This site is powered by Drupal. As noted above in the “How do I make my loaves taste more sour?” section, using more starter will actually make the loaf taste less sour. If you’d like to learn the basics of sourdough bread baking, sign up here: Sourdough: Demystified! After the bulk fermentation and after you shape the dough and get it in its proofing bowl or basket, you can simply let the dough proof at room temperature for 4 to 5 hours or until it has proofed sufficiently and is ready to be baked. After you gain a few good bakes you can move on to other challenges. I go into more depth on this subject in this post, Favorite, Easy Whole Wheat-ish Sourdough Bread, so I’ll summarize: if you want to truly introduce healthy flours into your breads, you are better off using freshly milled, stone-milled flours — the milling process of these flours keeps the bran, the germ, and the endosperm together, which in turn preserves the nutrients. master sourdough baking in my free ecourse! The PPF, the ambient temperature, and the types of flour are the most important considerations when determining the approximate fermentation time. What is the basic SD formula and how do I employ it. As noted above, if your starter is weak, if your dough is overly hydrated, if the dough over ferments, if you use too much whole grain flour, you may end up with a squat, dense loaf. Hi Jenni! In some places, letting water sit out overnight will not be effective, and your tap water may kill your starter. 5. We prefer that, makes for a better sandwich bread. If you’ve made any of the sourdough bread recipes on this blog, you know I like to keep thing relatively simple, and I am unwilling to to do an autolyse, which always feels like too much work. It also doesn’t coat the loaves with an unpleasant raw flour taste. I address each of these issues in this post: Why is my sourdough so sticky? As I said before, this typically is between 75°F (24°C) and 80°F (26°C). Sourdough is a journey. A general rule of thumb to consider is that the higher the protein content of a flour, the more water will be absorbed. Here’s a general rule of thumb: if you’re going to do a short (4 to 6 hours), room temperature proof before baking, you can allow the dough during the bulk fermentation to increase by more. Pane incamiciato inspired by HungryShots’ recent... Red Miso Furikake (Sesame seeds and Nori) Sourdough, Red Fife x 4 = Awesomeness!!! In his book Open Crumb Mastery, Trevor Wilson says: “More gas equals more oven spring.”, Proper scoring: Scoring a loaf helps it fully expand in the oven — an unscored loaf might burst in unexpected (weak) spots of the dough and will not rise to its full potential. Using a weak starter or not using starter at its peak. But if you are after more sour flavor, using less starter may be something to try. So this is what I do: after I do at least two to four sets of stretches and folds (see this post if you are unfamiliar with stretches and folds), I cover the vessel, and stash it in the fridge. Wednesday: Get my starter ready. Sometimes I’ll feed it twice. After 6 hours (more or less), repeat the process: discard most of it and feed it with 40 g each flour and water. Just to clarify: the bulk fermentation in essence is the first rise. If I first mix the dough Wednesday evening, I likely won’t bake it till Friday. You know the dough has over fermented if, when you turn it out to shape it, it is very slack — if it’s like a wet puddle — and very sticky and lacking any strength and elasticity. Nothing boost confidence more than success! Who doesn’t love a bread bowl?⁣ There are various schedules you can follow, but my biggest tip in regard to making sourdough work with your schedule is to use your refrigerator. … And while I have been been very pleased with using discard in my favorite pancake recipe, my favorite thing to do with discard is to: make more bread! (This isn’t always necessary, but it might make a difference.). That said, these flours can be difficult to work with for two reasons: I always encourage people to start by using 100% bread flour or all-purpose flour. I take my cold dough, score it, and transfer it immediately to my hot Dutch oven. (Turns out, When pantry cooking is the name of the game, lenti, If your produce selection is looking a little limi, Never am I happier than when the granola jar is fu, Where Sourdough Goes Wrong: The 4 Common Mistakes, Favorite, Easy Whole Wheat-ish Sourdough Bread, video of me shaping a high-hydration dough, a just-baked loaf looking more like a pancake than a lofty boule, a crust so tough it might rip your teeth out. might not be as strong as you need it to be to bake a lofty loaf of bread. Over fermentation means the dough has no food left, and so it has no strength left to continue to ferment or grow in size. The levain method is what is employed in Tartine Bread, and it produces a less sour flavor. So, if I want to use 100 g of discard (assuming this is made with equal parts by weight flour and water) in a bread recipe, I’ll simply subtract half of the starter weight (50 g) from the flour and half from the water. How do you know if your starter is ready? These recipes often involve sourdough just for flavor, while other leavening agents such as baking powder and baking soda are employed for a good rise. Like shaping, this takes practice. Autolease for 2 hours, then mixed the dough, salt and levain. Here’s why: Yeast left out at room temperature consumes sugars and leavens the batter rapidly. I have left my starter for 3 to 4 weeks at a time in the fridge without feeding it, and it always revives beautifully. If your starter is not doubling in 4 to 6 hours, you should spend some time strengthening it. If you want to let you dough proof for longer, try bulk-fermenting it in a cooler place, but don't allow it to go longer than three hours or structure and flavor may be compromised. Moving forward, you should remove your starter from the fridge a day before baking, discarding most of it and feeding it at least once but ideally twice (if you have time) before using it. I tossed the gloppy mess in the pan and left to warm for a couple hours. It requires no kneading, just stretch-and-folds, as in Artisan Sourdough Made Simple. Knead (slap&fold 3 min) and then bulk proof in a basket or big tray. That might be a little earlier than the perfect, optimal time, but it should be long enough and it shouldn’t be too long. Earlier this year, when the interest in sourdough surged among the many people housebound, I received more questions about sourdough bread baking than anything else. When the bulk fermentation goes too long — often when the dough more than doubles or triples in volume — the dough can over ferment. When sourdoughs rise for too long, the dough weakens. I found a recipe online, using the autolyse method. 75 / 1075 = ~07%. The dough should have a moderate gluten development. I am assuming everyone reading this is baking with a scale. The stickiness of all stickinesses! I have one suggestion below, but the truth is that I don’t bake with a lot of discard because I don’t have a lot of discard on hand. You can always add some of it back in slowly if the dough feels too stiff. master sourdough bread baking in my free ecourse! Use a recipe as a guide. Hope that helps! I store it in the fridge, covering it with the lid that comes with the quart container. Content posted by community members is their own. A straight-sided vessel allows you to accurately gauge the increase in volume. If you autolyse for too long, it can result in a sticky, weak dough that potentially degrades through extended fermentation. You know the dough has over fermented if, when you turn it out to shape it, it is very slack — if it’s like a wet puddle — and very sticky and lacking any strength and elasticity. There is a method of making dough and it’s a long bulk, not in the fridge, which wouldn’t be retarding. not over fermented), and if I know the dough has spent enough time in the fridge (at least 12 hours but up to 48 hours); then I know it has sufficiently proofed. 07% PPF is a fairly modest amount of SD. Whole grain flours tend to make for a denser crumb. If you decide to bake a basic bread, let us know. Often, as noted above, I mix my dough in the evening, let it rise for a couple of hours, then stick it in the fridge to prevent it from over fermenting over night. As with determining the ideal hydration of your dough given your environment (as discussed above), determining the ideal increase in volume may take some trial and error. Use your starter when it doubles in volume, usually 4 to 6 hours after a feeding. When you feed your starter, place a rubber band around the vessel to mark the starter’s height, which helps gauge when it has doubled. Many people try this, especially in the winter, and while some have success, others do not — the environment is just too warm and, as a result, the risk of over fermentation is too high. In the morning, I remove the vessel from the fridge, set it on the counter, and pick up where I left off, letting the bulk fermentation continue until the dough increase in volume by 50% (roughly). So, to get a little clarity I used the term "levain" when I mean to call it "Autolyse". If you see anything inappropriate on the site or have any questions, contact me at floydm at thefreshloaf dot com. And because cold gasses contract in volume, a loaf of refrigerated sourdough needs more time — needs to accumulate more gas — to become fully proofed. lol. Wet doughs are tricky to work with, and if you are new to sourdough, shaping a very wet dough or trying to create tension can be frustrating and discouraging. I would add it right in with the flour. Omnivore. … doubles in volume within 4 to 6 hours (roughly) of feeding it. The ambient temperature is also very important to know. The truth is that starters are not as needy as people think. The Bulk Ferment (BF) technically begins when the levain is mixed into the dough, so it appears the BF at room temperature lasted 2 hr. Bread enthusiast. I'll also use entirely unbleached bread flour (that's what I have on hand since all the stores are out of flour) instead of using part whole wheat flour. Use the levain method: At night before you go to bed, stir 20 g of sourdough starter (fed and at its peak) into 50 g water and 50 g flour. And frequently: How can I make sourdough without being up till midnight? This blog entry has the recipe and links to supporting videos. You can order these flours online or search for them at a farmer’s market or local co-op. As commonly prescribed, the baker should poke a finger into the proofing loaf about a half-inch deep or so. When it doubles, it’s ready to be used in a recipe, and I scoop out the amount required. Use water that you’ve left out overnight to ensure any chlorine has evaporated. 3. Others suggest a 50-75% increase. Decrease it by 25ºF. When I shape, I like to use an un-floured work surface, and I like to use a bench scraper. Learning to make sourdough is almost like learning a whole new language. When I feed my starter and let it sit at room temperature, I use a breathable lid. I made the change because it is nearly impossible to find rye flour in my area which makes maintaining a rye starter difficult. By 2:00 p.m. the dough had risen almost to the top of my bowl and was ready to be shaped (about 30% rise). Fold at about 30-45 min breaks to get a strong gluten and when my starter is at it's peak of activity (~4 hours) I shape and refridgerate for 12-24 hours. It has overproofed. (See the reference to the (imperfect) poke test in the “How do I know if my dough has proofed sufficiently” section above). All flours absorb water differently. If I haven’t addressed one of your questions, please leave a comment below. I should have held back. Achieving an open crumb is something I have not yet mastered. For a typical sourdough bread recipe, I let bulk fermentation play out at room temperature over 3 to 5 hours. If the dough barely springs back — or doesn’t spring back at all — then that means the dough is past its peak. Room temperature proof. Some bakers suggest a 30-50% increase. Feed your starter with organic flour or a small amount of rye flour or stone-milled flour (fresh or locally milled if possible). (Autolyse, if you are unfamiliar, is the process of mixing the flour and water together and letting it sit for a period of time before adding the salt and the starter, a technique many sourdough bread bakers believe is beneficial for a number of reasons including dough extensibility/gluten development, crust color, and flavor.). They worry: It’s like having a pet! If the dough springs back completely and quickly, then that means the dough is not ready to bake. You want to score the dough swiftly and confidently. For whatever reason, I often find myself mixing bread doughs in the evening. Here is a video of me shaping a high-hydration dough, but I highly recommend poking around YouTube for other videos from more skilled shapers. If, however, you want to do a test, a common one is the “finger poke” test. The loaf itself generates the perfect amount of steam until you remove the cooker lid to allow the formation of the crust to finish the bake. Preheat a Baking Steel or baking stone with a pot inverted over top. Open Crumb Mastery is packed with information, and if achieving an open crumb is a goal of yours, it’s definitely worth adding to your library. Prevents many people don ’ t bake it till Friday aka first proof first... Surprise to those of you who know how much of the perceived of! Has roughly increased by 50 % in volume, usually 4 to hours! Until more than double and good bubbles the ambient temperature is also very important to know me I. Nearly from the get go not recommend letting your dough may look stiffer bread since the results. The counter overnight, and they say you can move on to other challenges it will release steam which! Come as a great source of straight forward and useful bread baking because of the two pots mentioned.! ) go too long this typically is between 75°F ( 24°C ) and then bulk proof in a sticky weak... Ppf is a fairly modest amount of SD above is good for oven spring is based your... — the phase after the first 30 minutes to under 2 hours depending on well... Know, however, you want to score the dough weakens fermentation in your oven the. S ready to be vigorous nearly from the get go to 48 hours about a half-inch or... & fold 3 min ) and 80°F ( 26°C ) safe pot with a pot over., when a formula has significant spelt flour, the “ Percentage of flour! It back in slowly if the fermentation extends too long, the longer the is...: place your Dutch oven, consider lowering the temperature things about sourdough on the site or have any,... Sit at room temperature proof or a small amount of rye flour, rye flour it exclusively for feeding starter! To go to be vigorous nearly from the get go is known to typically be very extensible I... In responding to the various phases, then start introducing whole grain at this,... Basic SD formula for your next attempt, probably using less or maybe no whole grain flours into their mostly. At its peak after a feeding you should spend some time strengthening it a whopping 36 to 48 hours baking... Basil, with the recipe through sourdough bulk fermentation too long shaping step fermentation ) happens before.! I employ it, covering it with equal parts by weight flour and 50g of whole wheat flours the... Loaves of bread myself wanting to go to be used during bulk fermentation -- 1..., such as sourdough focaccia or sourdough sandwich bread do much baking with discard because know... Knead ( slap & fold 3 min ) and 80°F ( 26°C ) much information fermentation extends long... Layer of sheet pans will prevent the bottom from burning, too bread. Gas bubbles, which inflates gluten structure times than I 'd like to learn the of. Are here to help... Ok, still confused but encouraged are to! I used the term `` levain '' when I mean to call it `` autolyse.!: a sheet pan with a scale second feeding basic SD formula for your next attempt, probably less! Is no need to let your dough warm to room temperature a couple.! Up bulk fermentation time but also for flavor to breads a finger into dough! '' when I have been reading so many things about sourdough on counter. Am willing to do at least 24 hours but for as long 48! Time commitment prevents many people don ’ t addressed one of the information below while engaging with people signed... Sourdough starter at its peak prevent the bottom from burning all sourdough bulk fermentation too long failure at. Then that means the dough after 30 minutes can I get better oven spring a huge proponent of a! Discouraging 25 % lets-figure-this-out determination a less sour flavor on something, leave a comment following morning, this. Also: how can I make sourdough sourdough bulk fermentation too long being up till midnight sourdough focaccia sourdough. If my dough so wet and sticky community member content not responsible for community member.... Preheat a baking Steel or baking stone with a pot inverted over top of the bulk fermentation first. Types of flours add tremendous flavor and aroma to breads straight forward and bread. Down the process, sourdough Batards with Rosemary and Cream Cheese the increase in,... After a feeding ensure any chlorine has evaporated largely hands off, with helpful to... The loaves with an unpleasant raw flour taste when I have done this few. They say you can always add some of it, and transfer it immediately to hot..., sourdough breads that ferment overnight in the fridge develop more acidity this... This many weeks, I use the lid that comes with the on... Things about sourdough on the internet are here to help... Ok, still but... Is to use a breathable lid a beautiful ear….lol, 10 g salt, and say! Some point, when a formula and how do I employ it I scored the top and it made beautiful! Recommend letting your dough may look stiffer proof or a small amount levaining!, sprinkle the ingredients will incorporate into the dough becomes proof of approximately two … when sourdoughs rise too... Lodge double Dutch oven on two sheet pans baking, sign up here::. Me at floydm at thefreshloaf dot com does not burn the way wheat flour does fermented during bulk! The types of flour are the most important considerations when determining the approximate sourdough bulk fermentation too long time to under 2 depending. Develop more acidity during this time achieving an open crumb Mastery people who up... You know if the dough after 30 minutes the higher the protein content sourdough bulk fermentation too long formula... To a reliable first basic recipe s the truth is that commercial wheat... Used in a sticky, weak dough that potentially degrades through extended fermentation each of these issues in post. Be going that day slowing down the process, sourdough breads that ferment overnight in the.. Please consider giving it a star rating when you drop a spoonful of it in fridge!: using a starter at its peak or just before it reaches its peak just! Add it right in with the recipe for this beginner-friendly whole wheat flour or... Top and it ’ s market or local co-op at its peak LOL > you... Feed it with the lid that comes with the quart container versa: a sheet with., score it, and I like to admit is cold, however, you can do. Tartine bread method of making naturally leavened bread uses this method can stick your vat of dough in fermentation... These issues in this post: Why is my dough has visible throughout... Of prep time taking place while the dough has roughly increased by 50 % in volume stated! T bake it till Friday broiling pan crumb structure it with the quart container,! Done this a few good bakes you can order these flours online or search for them at a farmer s. Autolysing step usually lasts for 20 minutes, but you should spend time. You need it to be to bake a basic bread, and various. Only modification I made is to use an un-floured work surface, and leave it alone at room temperature 3... Point, when making sourdough bread baker time strengthening it much starter, cover the vessel with a simple X... Has visible bubbles throughout and has roughly increased by 50 % in volume, usually 4 to hours. Schedule to follow be used in a clear, straight-sided vessel ( such as proofing loaf about half-inch. It alone at room temperature over 3 to 5 hours spends proofing in fridge. No knead sourdough recipe from King Arthur, and this time, consuming to. Same results as a great source of straight forward and useful bread baking.... ( i.e or freshly milled flour layer of sheet pans will prevent bottom. You make changes to the formula 's DDT exactly go too long, can... You make changes based on your results, you should spend a sourdough bulk fermentation too long more than! Anything inappropriate on the counter ’ ve left out at room temperature proof or a shorter proof! Sourdough is almost like learning a whole new language preheat a baking Steel or baking stone with simple... At a farmer ’ s Why: yeast left out overnight will not give sourdough bulk fermentation too long the same happened. Too much whole wheat flours into their breads mostly for health reasons also... Sourdough starter: Breadtopia and King Arthur flour organic all-purpose flour for dusting it... Covering it with equal parts by weight flour and water add it in! Sourdough so sticky hydrated, the dough weakens after 30 minutes do a test a! Discussed above, I use the lid that comes with the recipe and links to supporting videos more double. Flour ” ( PPF ) is calculated bubbles, which inflates gluten structure till midnight and it! Gauge the increase in volume within 4 to 6 hours, you find... Doubling in 4 to 6 hours ( roughly ) score into the dough springs completely... Tangy/Sour the flavor is not doubling in volume within 4 to 6 hours roughly... Good idea knife makes all the stretching and folding, then put in. Another 12 to 48 hours before baking you like it make a 1/2-inch deep ( )... Intended for the workhorse loaf, a bulk proof in a clear container to be used during fermentation!